This month several authors are visiting my blog to talk about why they write in multiple genres. My first blogger this month is Shannon Donnelly. Please give her a warm welcome!
* *
Who am I This Time?
Writers write. But authors have identities. We get tagged with a genre. Stephen King = Horror. JK Rollings = Fantasy. Nora Roberts = Romance. Readers love to put us into boxes because that’s a known quantity—it’s difficult sometimes to look at all the books and figure out what’s going to give you that good read you want. So an author’s name can be a familiar, known quantity. But that box can become awfully tight. And, let’s face it, is there any author around who only reads one thing?
When I started out writing, I had the “what do I write” problem. I read everything—well, almost. I’m not fond of medical fiction. And I don’t read much that’s literary. In genre, there are westerns, mysteries, SF, fantasy, gothics, paranormal, romance, historical, and they’re all well represented on my bookshelves. So what to write? I’m happy to say I’ve been able to dip my fingers into several pies.
Computer games allowed me a chance to do fantasy. Thayer’s Quest came out for laser disc game systems back when those were a hot ticket item. I also got to work on the hit game Dragon’s Quest. The fantasy writing I’d been doing early in my writing career helped me get those writing gigs. But the fantasy market wasn’t where I wanted to live, so I kept looking around. A couple of mysteries later had me realizing that while they were fun, they weren’t home to me, either. The search ended when I started writing romances.
The cool thing with a romance is that it can have other elements. Mystery, fantasy, western-settings, and even SF can be worked in as the background for the story. But these sub-genres also carry their own boxes—not ever reader wants to cross from one to the other. And that’s the first thing a writer has to face—you’re not going to please everyone. Like the song goes, however, you might as well please yourself.
After eight Regency romances written and published with Kensington, the old itch came back. Time to spread my wings. A few YA horror novellas had helped me be happy with the writing. But it was time to try longer books. Paths of Desire—now out as an ebook—came out of the urge to try something new. But not too new. It was still set in Regency England, but it’s a historical romance. It’s darker, bigger, with more complicated themes and characters. And I love that book. It was also a bigger genre change than I had anticipated—there’s definitely a flavor to a Regency romance that marks it as separate from a Historical romance. Which brings us back to how do you deal with separate identities?
Jayne Ann Krentz has done it with pen names, but I’ve heard her speak at RWA conferences and say if she had it to do over, she’d keep the same name. Jo Beverley has kept the same name for her Medieval and her Georgian and her Regency romances, but she’s noted that not all her readers follow her over from one sub-genre to the next. So what’s an author to do?
It’s really all about the reader. I’m writing some paranormals again—this time for adults, not YA. And I’m planning to use the name Shannon Dee. It’s close enough to Shannon Donnelly, but it’s also going to let the reader know these are different from Shannon Donnelly books. This is because a Shannon Donnelly book is Regency or will be a Regency Historical and I want to set reader’s expectations. The different names give me a freedom to do different things. Because, for me, it’s about keeping the work fresh and fun and interesting. If I’m bored by my own writing, it’s not going to fascinate any readers. Which is why I want to write a lot of different things. And that’s the other expectation I have to set—I’m not going to be great at all of them.
It’s not always a bad thing to flop. Sometimes you learn more from trying something new and falling on your face with it. If nothing else, it teaches humility. And not to repeat that same failure. If you don’t try something new, you don’t really know your limits. But if you find one thing you love, there’s nothing wrong with staying with that, as well. Which is why I’ll always come back to writing Regency romance.
That’s the one thing I discovered when I looked closely at my bookshelves—I had more Regency romances than any other genre or subgenre. I love that time period and those books. I’m still reading them. I’m still writing them. But, to keep them fresh, I need other books in other genres both to read and write.
BIO
Shannon Donnelly’s writing has won numerous awards, including a RITA nomination for Best Regency, the Grand Prize in the “Minute Maid Sensational Romance Writer” contest, judged by Nora Roberts, RWA’s Golden Heart, and others. Her writing has repeatedly earned 4½ Star Top Pick reviews from Romantic Times magazine, as well as praise from Booklist and other reviewers, who note: “simply superb”…”wonderfully uplifting”….and “beautifully written.”
Her Regency romances can be found as ebooks on Kindle, Nook and at Smashwords. She also writes historical romance, paranromal romances, has had novellas published in several anthologies, has had young adult horror stories published, and is the author of several computer games. She lives in New Mexico with two horses, two donkeys, two dogs, and only one love of her life. She can be found online at sd-writer.com, facebook.com/sdwriter, and twitter/sdwriter.




